Recipe: Salted Caramel-Stuffed NYC Cookies

Sunday, 8 August 2021 06:00

These cookies are incredibly moreish.

“When thinking of cookies, you may think crunchy, or you may think gooey and soft. But do you think a gooey soft centre of caramel? Well, you absolutely should!” says blogger and baker, Jane Dunn.

“These cookies have a molten caramel centre that is absolutely incredible, along with a salted cookie dough.”

Salted caramel-stuffed NYC cookies from Jane’s Patisserie

Ingredients:
(Makes 8)

125g unsalted butter
175g soft light brown sugar
1 egg (medium or large)
1tsp vanilla extract
300g plain flour
1½tsp baking powder
½tsp bicarbonate of soda
1tsp sea salt
250g milk chocolate chips or chunks
8–16 soft caramel sweets

Salted caramel cookies (Ellis Parrinder/PA)

Method:

1. Beat the butter and soft light brown sugar together until creamy. Add the egg and vanilla extract and beat again.

2. Add the plain flour, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and sea salt and combine until a cookie dough is formed, then add the chocolate chips or chunks and mix until they are evenly distributed.

3. Portion your dough out into eight balls – each should weigh about 110g. Once rolled into balls, flatten slightly and put one or two soft caramels in the middle, then wrap the cookie dough around the caramels and re-roll into balls. Put into the freezer for at least 30 minutes, or in the fridge for an hour or so. While the cookie dough is chilling, preheat the oven to 200°C/180°C fan and line two baking trays with parchment paper.

4. Take your cookies out of the freezer or fridge and put onto the lined trays (I do four cookies per tray) and bake for 12–14 minutes. Once baked, leave the cookies to cool on the trays for at least 30 minutes as they will continue to bake while cooling.

CUSTOMISE

You can substitute the caramels for spreads, such as chocolate and hazelnut spread or biscuit spread. Simply freeze teaspoons of spread for at least 30 minutes, then wrap the cookie dough around the frozen spread in the same way.

The milk chocolate

More from Food and Drink

Mary Berry's Mediterranean All-in-One Chicken

This is a great way to feed the family as the chicken and veg are all cooked in one very large tray in the oven. It takes only minutes to put everything together then it sits in the oven for under an hour with no fussy finishing off to do and only one pan to wash up.
Recipe: Simple Fish Curry

Cooking a curry from scratch can feel a little daunting but this traditional Burmese recipe is really easy. Lightly spiced, warming and stunningly simple, this curry is one you’ll return to again and again
Recipe: Chocolate Peanut Buttercups

The dreamy combination of chocolate and peanut butter is indulgent and decadent so the perfect treat for Easter. These little beauties contain only a few ingredients (with a vegan option) and are quick and super easy to make
Recipe: Prune and Orange Hot Cross Buns

As a master baker and judge of ITV’s Britain’s Best Bakery, Peter Sidwell knows a thing or two about hot cross buns, as this fragrant and delicious recipe testifies.
Elvis Pancakes: With Bacon, Bananas & Peanut Butter

Named after the King of Rock, Elvis Presley – as they contain his favourite ingredients of bacon, bananas and peanut butter – these pancakes are packed with protein and nutrients. They’re also very easy to make.
Five Pancake Toppings You Need To Try For Pancake Day

Elevate your pancake game with these five irresistible toppings that will add a burst of flavour and excitement to your pancake day...
Recipe: Choux Hearts with Berries

Celebrity MasterChef contestant Lisa Faulkner knows full well that food is the language of love. So, what better way to woo your beloved on Valentine’s Day than with these stunning choux hearts?
Recipe: Truffled Macaroni & Smoked Haddock Bake

Want something that combines supreme comfort with a little decadence? Well look no further than this divine truffled macaroni dish with an extra boost from smoked haddock
Recipe: Nigel Slater's Lamb Hotpot

We’re getting to that time of the year when rustic food comes packed with extra appeal.
Recipe: Roasted Turkey Legs with Cranberries and Oranges

If you fancy something a little different on Christmas Day and don’t want to be bothered with cooking a whole turkey, this one-pot twist by Mary Goodwell is a vibrant, zesty dish that will delight your guests.
10 Eye-Catching Cocktails to Try This Christmas

The countdown to Christmas is officially on and the creativity is pouring out with everything from delicious desserts to eye-catching cocktails.
'Ever So Easy' Beef Bourguignon Recipe

This simple recipe by Adele Trathan virtually cooks itself, but it is deliciously succulent and flavoursome. It’s ideal for a wholesome meal when you don’t want to be slaving over a hot stove.
Coffee & Chocolate Banana Bread

This recipe by Mary Goodsell takes banana bread to a new level with the added flavours of chocolate and coffee. Soft and moist, it's a delicious mid-morning snack with a cup of coffee.
Recipe: Crispy Tofu with Sweet and Sour Peppers and Pineapple

Packed with veggies, this delicious vegan option offers the best of both flavours with its sweetness from the pineapple and tang from the vinegar.
Recipe: Black Forest Yoghurt Bark

This recipe by Mary Goodsell is delicious eaten straight from the freezer. It is an easy, protein filled snack that will also hit that sweet spot!
Lunchbox Ideas Everyone Will Love

As another academic year begins, we’ve been giving our lunchbox ideas a refresh.
Recipe: Chinese-Style Glazed Pork Belly

This Sunday (22nd) marks Chinese New Year. So we’re tucking in to a traditional Chinese dish, to celebrate the year of the rabbit!
Recipe: Spicy Barbecue Sizzlers

Some like it hot, so sizzle your ribs and chicken with these BBQ sauces. I hope you find these recipes melt-in-your-mouth incredible!
Kids Zone: Ice Cream Recipe

Turn an average summer’s day into a fun ice cream parlour adventure with this fun and easy homemade ice cream in a jar recipe, says Sara Whatley.
Coconut, Blueberry & Lemon No Bake Cheesecake

This cheesecake uses coconut yoghurt and plenty of zesty lemon for a healthier, lighter version of what tastes like a very decadent dessert

Recipe: Salted Caramel-Stuffed NYC Cookies

Share

More from Food and Drink

Get Social