Check out our latest magazine... Read Online

Pumpkin Pie with Chocolate Pastry

Approximately 13 million pumpkins are used in the UK for Halloween. Unfortunately most of these are only used for carving and then the flesh is discarded. What a waste!

Sadly most of it goes into general waste instead of being used for compost. With a little thought, the flesh can go a long way. It doesn’t always have a lot of flavour as they are grown for carving and can be pale and watery. You can turn them into something pretty special though, with a few spices and flavours.

This recipe for Pumpkin Pie with Chocolate Pastry is very tasty and a lovely dessert or coffee time snack. If you are really not interested in cooking and don’t have anyone to give your pumpkin flesh to, please at least make sure it finds its way on to a compost heap or into your food bin. This way it could provide food for lots of bugs and worms/slow worms as well as creating a rich soil for next year’s crops! 

 

INGREDIENTS

  • 500g plain flour
  • 50g cocoa powder
  • 125g unsalted butter, diced
  • 160g icing sugar
  • 2 eggs
  • 2 yolk
  • 2 tsp ground cinnamon

METHOD

  1. Rub the flour, cocoa, butter, icing sugar and cinnamon between your fingers to a breadcrumb consistency. 
  2. Add in the egg and extra yolk and mix to a dough but don’t overwork. Rest in the fridge for at least 1 hour.
  3. Roll the pastry on a lightly floured surface to about 3mm thickness and rest for another 5 minutes.
  4. Cut into discs and then press into greased tart cases.
  5. Dock the bases with a fork and then freeze hard. 
  6. Line with cling film or paper and fill with baking beans or your pastry trimmings. You can use these after cooking to make a crumble for another pudding or for your ice cream to sit on. 
  7. Bake at 160C until set and firm/no longer shiny
  8. Eggwash to seal any holes in the pastry

FOR THE FILLING

  • 1 small pumpkin (1kg ish)
  • 3 eggs
  • 250g dark brown sugar
  • 1 tbsp cornflour
  • 1.5 tsp ground cinnamon
  • ½ tsp ground ginger
  • ½ tsp mixed spice
  • ½ tsp ground mace
  • 240ml double cream
  • 60g coconut yoghurt

METHOD

  1. Peel the pumpkin and de-seed – you can re-use the seeds by following the tip at the bottom of the page. 
  2. Cut the pumpkin into quarters and roast at 180C until cooked through. Blend to a puree.
  3. Weigh 450g of the puree and then add o the remaining ingredients and mix well with a whisk. 
  4. Pour into the warm tart cases and then return to the oven at 160C and bake until set. It will rise a little but you can get away with filling the cases pretty much to the top. 
  5. They should take about 20 minutes but will be set firm when ready.
  6. Leave to cool slightly before removing from the moulds and serving at room temperature. 

TIPS:

  1. Most pumpkins in this country are grown for carving and so are pretty hollow inside, watery and have little flavour. That’s why a lot of people think they don’t like pumpkin! Try using a Crown Prince variety or another type of squash. The colour is much better too. 
  2. Boil the seeds in salted water for 10 minutes and then strain and bake until golden. They make a tasty and healthy snack. The ones you buy from the shop are green because it is the inner kernel only. These are really hard to remove but you can eat the whole thing anyway, they are just not so pretty. You could just plant them for next year if you want to. 
  3. Don’t keep rolling your pastry trimmings out as this will make your pastry too short but you can bake them off and use for a crumble or rough biscuits!
  4. Figs are also in season and add a nice bitter sweetness to this dish. Roast them with a little honey.
  5. If you have any pumpkin puree left you could add it to a soup, use it as a puree to accompany your dinner or sweeten it with a little honey and serve it with your pumpkin pie!

More from Food and Drink

  • Recipe: Hearty Beef & Pumpkin Stew

    This is the perfect, homely dinner to look forward to as the autumn nights draw in. Adele Trathan explains how to make this delicious casserole that is baked and served straight from the pumpkin

  • Recipe: William Shatner’s Cappuccino Muffins!

    Even in outer space, there’s nothing quite like a cappuccino muffin. Star Trek legend William Shatner goes boldly into the kitchen and delivers the goods...

  • Recipe: Red Velvet Cupcakes

    Deliciously light and fluffy, these red velvet cupcakes with a gorgeous soft cheese frosting are ideal for an afternoon tea – they are sure to impress your guests.

  • Recipe: Saffron & Lemon Chicken Joojeh Kebabs

    This probably features on the menu of every Persian restaurant in the world, the marinade of yogurt and lemon juice tenderises the meat beautifully. This simplified version can be made at home in a conventional oven or grill if you don’t have a barbecue

  • Recipe: Raspberry Blancmange

    Based on a retro classic, this blancmange is a far cry from its wobbly 1970s reputation – instead, this is a light and creamy raspberry and almond dessert

  • South Carolina BBQ Chicken Thighs

    Try this winning BBQ chicken recipe from Grillstock founders Jon Finch and Ben Merrington and learn how to make both an authentic South Carolina BBQ sauce, and their secret BBQ rub.

  • Recipe: Local Lemon and Thyme Sea Bass

    This delicious recipe, courtesy of JBs Cowes, makes the perfect summer dish served with new potatoes.

  • Recipe: Sizzling Spare Ribs with BBQ Sauce

    The perfect spare ribs for your summer barbeque!

  • Recipe: Olive Oil, Pistachio & Lemon Cake

    This simple but delicious cake is made in a food processor, so it takes just minutes to prepare. Serve it with a simple lemon and sugar glaze and sprinkle with a few roughly chopped pistachios and dried rose petals

  • Recipe: Salted Caramel Praline Brownie

    Baker and author of Postal Bakes, Lucy Burton, will have you drooling at these divine brownies.

  • Mary Berry's Mediterranean All-in-One Chicken

    This is a great way to feed the family as the chicken and veg are all cooked in one very large tray in the oven. It takes only minutes to put everything together then it sits in the oven for under an hour with no fussy finishing off to do and only one pan to wash up.

  • Recipe: Simple Fish Curry

    Cooking a curry from scratch can feel a little daunting but this traditional Burmese recipe is really easy. Lightly spiced, warming and stunningly simple, this curry is one you’ll return to again and again

  • Recipe: Chocolate Peanut Buttercups

    The dreamy combination of chocolate and peanut butter is indulgent and decadent so the perfect treat for Easter. These little beauties contain only a few ingredients (with a vegan option) and are quick and super easy to make

  • Recipe: Prune and Orange Hot Cross Buns

    As a master baker and judge of ITV’s Britain’s Best Bakery, Peter Sidwell knows a thing or two about hot cross buns, as this fragrant and delicious recipe testifies.

  • Elvis Pancakes: With Bacon, Bananas & Peanut Butter

    Named after the King of Rock, Elvis Presley – as they contain his favourite ingredients of bacon, bananas and peanut butter – these pancakes are packed with protein and nutrients. They’re also very easy to make.

  • Five Pancake Toppings You Need To Try For Pancake Day

    Elevate your pancake game with these five irresistible toppings that will add a burst of flavour and excitement to your pancake day...

  • Recipe: Choux Hearts with Berries

    Celebrity MasterChef contestant Lisa Faulkner knows full well that food is the language of love. So, what better way to woo your beloved on Valentine’s Day than with these stunning choux hearts?

  • Recipe: Truffled Macaroni & Smoked Haddock Bake

    Want something that combines supreme comfort with a little decadence? Well look no further than this divine truffled macaroni dish with an extra boost from smoked haddock

  • Recipe: Nigel Slater's Lamb Hotpot

    We’re getting to that time of the year when rustic food comes packed with extra appeal.

  • Recipe: Roasted Turkey Legs with Cranberries and Oranges

    If you fancy something a little different on Christmas Day and don’t want to be bothered with cooking a whole turkey, this one-pot twist by Mary Goodwell is a vibrant, zesty dish that will delight your guests.

Get Social